← The build Svenska

The build · The obstacle

I submitted nine apps in a week. Apple rejected all nine as spam.

In October 2026 MassBuilder, then called PunchSet, was rejected under guidelines 4.3 and 4.2.6. Apple did not want a new build. They wanted answers to nine questions.

In the autumn of 2026 I had a plan that I thought was clever. Lots of small apps at a dollar each, no subscriptions, all in the same style, like a shelf in a shop. In one week I submitted nine apps to Apple. One of them was the gym log that is now called MassBuilder and was then called PunchSet.

On October 5 the gym log was rejected. The same days, the other eight were rejected too.

What Apple wrote

For the gym log Apple pointed to two of its guidelines. 4.3 is about spam: apps that repeat something that already exists, or that are variants of each other. 4.2.6 is about apps made with templates or services that generate apps.

The message did not ask for a new build. If you believe the app meets the requirements, do not resubmit it, it said. Answer these questions instead. There were nine, and in short they went like this:

  1. What does the app do, and what problem does it solve? Don't use the store description.
  2. Who is it for?
  3. What gap does it fill that other apps don't?
  4. How was it beta tested, and which feedback from testers changed the build?
  5. Is it standalone or part of a suite?
  6. Could it have been a feature in another app on your account?
  7. Does it share code with your other apps?
  8. Does it share code with someone else's app?
  9. Was it built for a client?

Why I got caught

It is easy to believe that Apple reviews one app at a time. But five of the nine questions were about what surrounds the app: the account, the other apps, shared code and who it was built for. From Apple's side my account looked like this that week: nine new apps in seven days, several of them built on the same shared code, and two gym logs from the same developer in the same category, because my old app WillTrack was still in the store.

Question 6 pointed straight at WillTrack. Question 4 pointed straight at me, because the beta testing was me.

What I answered

The reply box in App Store Connect takes 4,000 characters, so the answer had to go in two parts. What it said was true, including where the truth was thin.

On beta testing I answered that the testing had been informal: me, on my own phone throughout the build, and three friends who had tried the app. No public beta. On top of that there were 263 automated tests, which I suspect nobody at Apple counted as testers.

On the old app I answered that WillTrack was flawed at its foundation and had to be replaced entirely, not patched, and that it had been removed from sale in every country that same day.

At the end of the reply there was a paragraph nobody had asked for: that the code is written with AI tools that I direct, and that the app doesn't come from a template or an app generator. I chose to say it openly.

Meanwhile I kept building on what makes the app its own: a verdict from the app's judges every Monday, a second rest game where you balance a barbell by tilting the phone, and a suggestion of a lighter weight after two misses.

  • PunchSet's first store image, One tap per set: a workout where every set is a hole in a punch card.
  • PunchSet's store image Judged every Monday, with a Case closed stamp on the weekly verdict.
  • PunchSet's store image Skip leg day. Get judged, where a drawn chicken comments on leg day.
The store images that went with the resubmission: the punch card, the weekly verdict and the chicken.

What happened

I pressed the button to resubmit at 22:11 on October 7. Then nothing happened for just over eight days. On October 18 I released the app.

The small apps on the shelf I shut down. The shelf went completely off the rails. I still think the idea was good, and that Apple shouldn't see it as something negative, but since then almost all my time has gone to a single app.

If you get the same message

  • Read the questions as a description of what Apple sees. Every question is a suspicion. Question 6 means: you have another app that does the same thing.
  • Remove the overlap before you answer. I pulled WillTrack from the store the same day I replied.
  • Submit one app at a time. Nine in a week looks like a factory, whatever the apps do.
  • Answer the beta question truthfully. Three friends are three friends.
  • Say how the app is built. Guideline 4.2.6 is about templates and app generators. An app written with AI but built on your own decisions is something else, and that can be explained.

Questions and answers

What is App Store guideline 4.3?
It covers spam: apps that duplicate content or functionality already on the App Store, or several variants of the same app.
What is guideline 4.2.6?
It covers apps created from commercial templates or app generation services that are not submitted by the provider of the app's content.
Does Apple approve apps written with AI?
MassBuilder is written with AI tools and was approved after I said so in my reply to Apple. The questions were about templates, shared code and overlap with other apps, not about which tool wrote the code.
How long did approval take?
The app was rejected on October 5, 2026, resubmitted on October 7 and released on October 18. Later versions have been reviewed in 24 to 39 minutes, or waited almost six days.